IVsource home

IVsource.net Home

February 2001

A Look at Advanced Vehicle Control Systems Research in Europe
IVsource.net
1 March
2001

A broad overview of AVCSS projects at both the European and national levels -- altogether quite a robust and multi-faceted set of activities.


In Europe, Advanced Vehicle Control and Safety Systems (AVCSS) research and development is addressed both at the European level and the national level.  This report addresses European-wide activities first, then national activities on a country-by-country basis.

Notes that programs in Europe are quite multi-faceted -- although we expect we've been fairly comprehensive in this report, there may be yet other activities we didn't come across in this phase of our research.

Activity at the European Level


Overview   |   Fourth Framework Program   |   Fifth Framework Program   

Overview

European level work is performed through the sponsorship of the European Commission.  The European Commission has defined a focus area called the Information Society Technologies Program (INFOSO).  A stated objective of this focus area is to "build the mobile society within the information society," and in-vehicle systems are addressed accordingly.

Another EC focus area is Transportation and Environment (TREN), which takes a big-picture approach to assessing the benefits of particular transport technologies -- some believe that significant work in automated highway systems, for instance, would emerge from this area.

Currently, INFOSO is most active in the area of Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS), defined as a combination of telematics and vehicle control systems that assist drivers and reduce driver error rates.  Telematics is a broad term used to refer to any means of enabling information flow to the vehicle from external sources.  A fundamental principle of ADAS is that the driver remains responsible for the vehicle at all times and can override any automatic controls.

The critical applied technologies that fall under the European ADAS umbrella are:

  • computer vision

  • range measurement sensors

  • sensor fusion

  • road geometry monitoring and positioning

  • vehicle-vehicle and vehicle-roadside communications

  • human - machine interaction

  • traffic situation analysis and monitoring

  • control algorithm development and simulation

  • vehicle control systems

[back to Europe Level Activities]

Fourth Framework Program

Predecessor work in Europe that directly underpins today's programs was done under the EC's "Fourth Framework" research and development program, which ran from 1994-1998.  Most of these projects are now finished or nearly finished; some of the more important projects were as follows:

  • Urban Drive Control:  infrastructure-based communications of speed limits; also provision of green / red changes at traffic signals to allow assisted deceleration and take-off.

  • Anti-Collision Assist:  collision warning (including detection of stationary objects) and collision avoidance using sensor fusion

  • LACOS:  support for lane keeping and lane changes

  • IN-ARTE:  integration of data from on-board map databases and collision avoidance systems, which is expected to help especially in rural areas

  • SAVE:  driver monitoring and warning systems to detect driver impairment and perform limited emergency handling if the driver is incapacitated

  • CHAUFFEUR:  electronic coupling of control systems for large trucks (called electronic tow-bar), using vehicle-vehicle communications and sensing.  Cost-benefit analyses conducted showed a positive result of 4.4.

  • RESPONSE:  non-technical issues such as consumer perspectives; system dependability, testing, and certification; regulations; and liability/legal aspects were addressed by a group including automakers and lawyers from all the major European countries

  • AHSEA:  also called ADASE (ADAS Europe) looked at technology gaps, market aspects, and deployment scenarios in a process which involved the vehicle industry, infrastructure operators, and governments.  The consensus deployment path developed  (generally spoken of in the context of a 20 year period)  which is shown in the box below.


Predicted Phasing of ADASE Deployment
From the AHSEA Project
- 20 Year Timeframe -

Adaptive Cruise Control

  Lane Departure Warning

    Forward Collision Warning

      ACC Stop&Go

        Parking Assistant

          Road Departure Warning

            Blind Spot Monitoring

              ACC Stop&Go with lateral support

                Lane Change / Merge Assistant

                  Rural Drive Assistant

                    Crossing Assistant

                      Urban Drive Assistant

                        Trajectory Calculation

                          Automated Driving

[back to Europe Level Activities]

Fifth Framework Program

Best on ASHEA and other 4th Framework Results, the 5th Framework Program was launched in 1998 and runs through 2002.  

Overall areas of focus are:

  • development of more advanced sensor systems and data fusion

  • integration of multiple driver assist functions (with emphasis on human-machine interface)

  • more extensive evaluation in real world environments with field trials

  • supply chain issues

  • implementing a more supportive infrastructure to augment autonomous systems

  • development and implementation of operational concepts using ADAS

  • standardization and international cooperation

Projects are awarded based on proposal "calls" which are opened approximately every year.  A new call for proposals will open in June 2001.

Based on previous calls, key ADAS 5th Framework Programs already underway are:

  • ADASE II:  continues to examine deployment paths and market issues

  • RADARNET:  improved radar technology  -- development of a low cost multifunctional 77 GHz near and far distance sensors for urban collision avoidance, pre-crash detection, collision warning, stop&go, and parking aid

  • CARSENSE:  development of sensor fusion and architectures to support low speed automatic driving for complex traffic and driving situations

  • NEXTMAP:  identifying new map database requirements for ADAS, and testing/evaluation as to the technical / economic feasibility of these new maps

  • COMMUNICAR:  development of a harmonized human-machine interface that manages information from ADAS, telematics services, infotainment services, and basic vehicle information (speed, etc.)

  • CHAMELEON:  development of a pre-crash sensor system covering all areas around the vehicle, and new approaches to safety restraint systems

  • PROTECTOR:  to enhance the safety of vulnerable road users (pedestrians, bicyclists, motorcyclists), which account for 26% of road fatalities in Europe, this project is developing and testing cooperative systems (transponders carried by vulnerable road users) to enhance detection by drivers

  • CHAUFFEUR II:  for this second phase, a "Chauffeur Assistant" has been defined which develops the electronic tow-bar capability into a marketable product, allowing an equipped truck to follow any other truck at a safe distance.  The basic function combines ACC with lane-keeping

  • RESPONSE II -- in entering a second phase, the team expects  to work with the European Commission to establish a commonly accepted "Code of Practice" for design and validation of  ADAS and also address standardization procedures.

Additionally, the eEurope 2002 program has been defined,  which has Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS) as one of ten action areas focused on "an Information Society for All."  The ITS element includes a goal to have active safety systems in all new vehicles.  An eEurope ITS chapter is being inititated, to kick-start new solutions and accelerate R&D and deployment.

More information about EC programs can be found at http://www.cordis.lu/en/home.html; point to "European Union Funded Research," then click on "Promoting a User-Friendly Information Society."

[back to Europe Level Activities]

Activity at the National Level


France   |   Germany   |   The Netherlands   |   Sweden   |   United Kingdom

France

La Route Automatisée

La Route Automatisée (LaRA) focuses on the evolution of ADAS towards fully automated driving.  Recent work has focused on a deployment path study conducted for the "suburban" scenario, one of four RA scenarios (the other three are rural, trucking, and long distance inter-city).

 Four phases have been defined:

 >Phase 1 (Low Speed Automation)

Phase 1 introduces completely automated driving at low speeds for light vehicles in certain network sections -- the aim is to improve comfort in congested sections.  LSA would operate on designated lanes, but mixed with manual traffic.  Typical speeds would be 40 - 60 km/hr.  Low speed automation is seen as a natural convergence of perception and control products.  Simultaneously, in Phase 1, various active safety warning systems become available. 

 >Phase 2 (Dedicated Lanes)

In this phase, dedicated lanes (DLs) are reserved for automated vehicles, when there are a high number of equipped vehicles (due to Phase 1).  "Reservations" are made on these dedicated lane facilities and users gain higher safety and higher speed.  Here, travel times for automated vehicles are reduced, safety starts to improve, and congestion starts to decrease.  Overall, interest is increased, which further stimulates deployment.  Also during this phase, the best warning systems are installed on all new vehicles and active safety systems appear that incorporate vehicle control.  Safety and efficiency improves for the entire road network.

>Phase 3 (Equipment Extension)

This phase sees the number of equipped cars and reserved lanes increase.  DLs form an automated network, with centralized control for speed and vehicle-vehicle intervals.  At the same time, all new cars are equipped with active safety devices, and all cars are equipped with warning systems.

In this phase, user benefits are extended to long distance travel, centralized network control allows higher safety and capacity, and congestion reduction provides environmental benefits.

>Phase 4 (Generalisation)

Here, a high number of equipped vehicles exist, and all new highways are built for automated travel.  Automation is available throughout the entire network.  All critical parts of the network are centrally controlled, resulting in the highest benefits.

Timeframes for these phases are difficult to predict, but can be estimated as follows:

  • Phase 1:  Low Speed Automation on the market within 3-5 years and fully in the market by 2010.

  • Phase 4:  2030 is a reasonable expectation.

  • Other phases:  researchers believe they cannot be specific about the timing of Phases 2 and 3, as this depends on market forces and many other factors.

 Automated public transport, automated trucking, and automated vehicles in mixed traffic without dedicated lanes, are other deployment scenarios which could proceed in parallel.

Driver Support for Transit Buses

The CiViS system, which provides automatic lateral control for Bus Rapid Transit and precision docking, is being installed in the French cities of Claremont-Ferrand and Rouen.  Systems are expected to be in operation in 2001.

[back to National Level Activities]

Germany

INVENT

This is a partnership between German auto companies (BMW, DaimlerChrysler, Volkswagen) and the German Research Ministry to conduct advanced development of ADAS, in coordination with European programs.  The advanced functions defined by ASHEA/ADASE (see above) are expected to be the main focus.  INVENT has been recently established as the successor program to MOTIV, which ran during the late nineties.

[back to National Level Activities]

The Netherlands

Automated Vehicle Guidance

The Dutch Ministry of Transport has adopted a new National Traffic and Transport Plan to accommodate safety and mobility growth.  Automated Vehicle Guidance (AVG) trials are scheduled to begin in 2001, with broader development of AVG ongoing between 2000-2005.  Plans call for trials of Lane Departure Warning Systems (LDWS) with large trucks during 2001 - 2003.  While not yet funded, an Autonomous Speed Assistant is proposed for 02-04, and an External Speed Assistant pilot for 02-07.

Connekt

The public-private Connekt organization has been established to develop AVG and perform pilots and demonstrations.   Connekt is expected to focus on stop & go ACC, electronic coupling of vehicles, rural and urban road safety, automatic trains, and automated vehicles in urban traffic.

Intelligent Speed Adaptation

An Intelligent Speed Adaptation (ISA) trial began in 1999 in the  town of Tilburg, using the approach that speed adjustments are automatic (no driver involvement or choice).  Twenty cars are equipped for a one year test.  Information about the legal posted speed is stored in a geographical database, and the car contains this database as well as a GPS receiver to establish its position.  There are no roadside elements in this version of the system.  Technical issues and user acceptance are being evaluated; also, impacts on emissions, safety, and energy consumption.  Dutch officials say that a more advisory version of the system is likely to be deployed in the future.

Transit

A laterally guided bus system is being implemented for the city of Eindhoven.

[back to National Level Activities]

Sweden

Intelligent Speed Adaptation

Sweden is taking a worldwide lead in evaluation of the benefits of Intelligent Speed Adaptation, with over 7000 vehicles currently participating in an operational test.  ISA is sponsored by the Swedish National Road Authority (SNRA), who is investing $9M in the project, as part of a vision for achieving zero traffic fatalities and injuries.  During 1999-2002, cars are being equipped with voluntary speed adaptation systems to help motorists keep to speed limits.  Systems are being deployed in four cities.  Two approaches are used -- the advisory system, in which the driver is notified if his speed is too high, and an "active accelerator," in which resistance is activated in the accelerator if the driver attempts to speed up when his speed is at or above the speed limit.  The accelerator force can be over-ridden, if necessary.  For the road information, both digital maps / GPS are being used (three cities), as well as roadside beacons using dedicated short range communications (DSRC) -- at least in one city.

[back to National Level Activities]

United Kingdom

 Vision 2030

Sponsored by the UK Highways Agency, Vision 2030 aims to identify a longer-term vision for inter-urban transport, using the approach of transferring control of the vehicles from the driver to an infrastructure-linked control system (automated highway) to optimize operation and manage access.

Foresight Vehicle

The UK's Foresight Vehicle program (supported by the Department of Trade and Industry) works with the domestic auto industry to perform product-oriented and longer term R&D.  One Foresight project in the AVCSS arena is called Future Antenna Technology for Cars and Trucks (FATCAT1), in which the feasibility and early designs of future antennas for vehicles has been examined.   The project is examining 63 GHz antenna designs to enable vehicles to communicate with each other to form co-operative platoons, to use collision avoidance systems, and to alert drivers to maneuvers by other vehicles.  The antenna designs are also expected to support vehicle-roadside communications.   Challenges are to realize all-around coverage, handle safety-critical messaging, achieve low cost, and conform to car styling.  The project has so far succeeded in identifying candidate antenna designs and work is continuing for FATCAT2.  Further information can be found at www.foresightvehicle.org.uk.

Intelligent Speed Adaptation

Various versions of Intelligent Speed Adaptation systems are being studied and tested.   Regarding ISA benefits, UK studies have shown substantial predicted accident reductions for fixed speed systems, variable speed systems (which change depending on geography), and dynamic systems (which adjust speeds based on actual current traffic conditions).  Benefits were greatest for dynamic systems with mandatory speed control.  Based on trials, mandatory ISA seems to be particularly effective in reducing speed on highways as vehicles pass through villages.  Research indicates that speed limiters are generally acceptable to the public, especially to residents, and that speed limiters appear to be the most effective way to control speed.  Using GPS combined with a digital map which includes speed limit information, an infrastructure-independent ISA system has also been examined.   However, this approach can only provide fixed speed limits.  Research to date indicates that, with infrastructure assistance to provide speed limits based on current weather and traffic conditions, the greatest benefits can be gained.  New pilots for a second stage of research are now beginning.

[back to National Level Activities]

[Top]




Copyright 2001: IVsource.net and Richard Bishop Consulting (RBC).
All Rights Reserved.
IVsource home

IVsource.net Home

February 2001